Get the 200+ Page Optimal Living Daily Workbook (PDF) - Free.
Want to turn today's episode into an actionable plan? Join the Optimal Living Weekly newsletter and I'll send you our 200-page digital workbook immediately. It's packed with the best takeaways from the show, formatted for easy reading and implementation at home.
Get your free PDF workbook here: https://oldpodcast.eo.page/join
Discover all of the podcasts in our network, search for specific episodes, get the Optimal Living Daily workbook, and learn more at: OLDPodcast.com
Episode 3749:
Kumiko explains the appeal of percentage-based budgeting rules like 50/30/20, including their simplicity, then lays out where they break down, especially on lower incomes and when lifestyle inflation creeps in. She makes the case for zero-based budgeting instead, giving every dollar a job so your budget reflects your own priorities and money management goals.
Read along with the original article(s) here: https://www.thebudgetmom.com/should-you-budget-your-money-using-percentages/
Quotes to ponder:
"To me, it never makes sense to spend more just because you make more."
"There is a point where frugality no longer helps."
"The bottom line, if your budget is not forcing you to be more intentional with your money, it's not working."
Optimal Finance Daily is a daily personal finance podcast where we narrate the best articles on financial independence, investing, saving money, and money management, read to you by a professional narrator so you can grow your wealth a little more every day.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
[00:00:00] Observe, the North American Dad, 50s, great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana, an offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, dang, that's a good offer. The highest form of approval. No haggling, no hassle. No one called him boss. He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
[00:00:31] This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18+.
[00:00:54] This is Optimal Finance Daily. Should you budget your money using percentages? By Kumiko of thebudgetmom.com. And I'm Justin Malek, your narrator, reading to you from the best articles online every day of the year. So let's continue the tradition as we optimize your life. Should you budget your money using percentages? By Kumiko of thebudgetmom.com.
[00:01:25] One topic I'm frequently asked about by listeners is percentage budgeting. There are a lot of articles out there that give you a very clear outline of where you should be spending your money, and what percentage of your take-home income should be spent on predetermined categories, such as saving, debt payoff, and required expenses.
[00:01:44] For example, a percentage-based budget might set aside 10-15% for food, 25-35% for housing, 10-15% in savings, and 10-15% for charitable giving. Another example is Elizabeth Warren's book, All Your Worth. She suggests people spend 50% on required expenses,
[00:02:10] housing, housing, food, utilities, transportation, and so on, 30% on wants, and 20% should be spent on paying off debt or saving. Both of these examples make sense on paper, but the real question is, does using these types of percentage restraints really work? Pros of percentage budgeting.
[00:02:34] Percentage-based budgeting is simple. It uses and relies on the percentage of your income to determine how much you can spend and where. Some people believe that having a percentage-based budget feels less restricting. When you dedicate a specific dollar amount to a category, like $500 for food, it feels limiting. If you think about your food budget as 10% of your income, mentally, it seems limitless somehow.
[00:03:02] There is a mental boost thinking about percentages rather than a specific dollar amount. All spending categories benefit when there are life changes. If you get a raise at work or a bonus, your take-home pay has increased, which means all categories in your budget benefit. Instead of using that extra income to only pay off debt or save for a down payment on a house,
[00:03:27] which is only benefiting one category, a percentage-based budget uses that money to increase all categories, with more money for food, required expenses, debt, and saving. Cons of percentage budgeting. The most significant problem using your take-home pay to determine how much you should spend is that it doesn't work well with different income levels, especially low ones.
[00:03:53] For example, if you are a single mother who lives in an area where housing costs are high and have a new-ish car you're still paying off, it's almost impossible to keep your spending within the percentage guidelines. There are going to be some instances where your personal life just doesn't conform to these percentage rules. There are financial experts out there who say that the solution would be to cut down on those required expenses by being more frugal.
[00:04:22] For example, you can move to a less expensive house and sell your car for something cheaper. Let me be very clear. I'm all for saving as much as I can and cutting costs where I see the opportunity. But there's only so much you can do. There's a point where frugality no longer helps. I have lived paycheck to paycheck. I know what it's like to want to save and cut expenses, only to find yourself in a position where there is nothing left to cut.
[00:04:52] That's the hard truth about finance and money. There's only so much you can do without drastically reducing your quality of life. What should you do? Downgrade your home? Sell your new-ish car and get an older one that has good gas mileage and cheaper insurance? In reality, those seem like doable steps, but there are options people rarely want to take, and that's reality. My opinion.
[00:05:22] It doesn't matter how you budget your money. Every single budget, even the simplest one, is entirely dependent on the personal life and experiences of the person creating it. That means budgeting using percentages will not work for everyone. The number one thing you have to remember is that following someone else's budget without evaluating your own specific situation will never work, at least not for the foreseeable future.
[00:05:50] One of the most significant flaws I see with percentage-based budgeting is that it does not deal with the problem of lifestyle inflation, which is a financial killer. Lifestyle inflation is increasing your spending when your income goes up. This makes it especially challenging to get out of debt, save for retirement, or meet bigger financial goals. In fact, percentage-based budgeting has it built right into the model.
[00:06:17] If your income increases by $2,000 every month, using a percentage-based budget, what you spend on specific categories is directly tied to your take-home pay. With such an income raise, your budget is now telling you that you can spend $1,500 on housing when you are perfectly happy and doing just fine in your $800 apartment. To me, it never makes sense to spend more just because you make more.
[00:06:45] In my opinion, percentage-based budgeting leaves too much room for error. It does not combat reckless spending and doesn't allow you to budget for things that are truly important for your personal life. Another solution. If you are going to use percentage-based budgeting, you have to make sure that the percentages that you are using align with your long-term financial goals, plain and simple. If you genuinely want to be specific with your budget
[00:07:13] and create something that will work, I highly recommend zero-based budgeting. It will force you to give each dollar you earn a job and is created entirely around the needs and priorities of the creator. I have been a zero-based budgeter from the beginning, and since starting, my financial picture has changed drastically. It has changed my relationship with money, and I'm no longer stressed about how I'm spending my money.
[00:07:41] I know exactly where it's going and why. The bottom line? If your budget is not forcing you to be more intentional with your money, it's not working. The whole point of a budget is to make you aware of where your money is going so you can make better and wiser spending decisions. If it's not accomplishing this, what's the point? You just listened to the post titled,
[00:08:08] Should You Budget Your Money Using Percentages? by Kumiko of thebudgetmom.com. And I'll be right back with my commentary. Many leaders think they know where time goes, but as teams grow and tools multiply, reality can look surprisingly different. So decisions about what to automate and where AI fits can be a gut call. That's the problem today's sponsor, Scribe, is helping solve. Scribe is a specialized intelligence platform
[00:08:36] trusted by 94% of the Fortune 500. And Scribe Optimize is where your AI roadmap starts. It automatically captures how your team works across approved business apps, showing what's happening, how often, and where time is lost without interviews or guesswork. Using that workflow data, Optimize then identifies what's holding teams back and pinpoints high-impact opportunities to improve or automate with data-backed ROI projections.
[00:09:05] Plus, privacy and security are built in. Optimize runs only on apps your admin approves, user-level data is anonymized by default, and sensitive data is redacted. To see Optimize in action, head to scribe.how slash OFD and mention our show for a 30-day risk-free trial. That's S-C-R-I-B-E dot H-O-W slash OFD. You're listening to a quick ad. You know what else is quick?
[00:09:33] Selling your car on Carvana. Just put in your vehicle information and we'll give you an offer. Done. No hassle. No negotiation. No guy from an online listing lowballing you. Which means, by the time I'm done explaining this, you could have basically done it. Still haven't started? Hey, better late than never. Sell your car today on Carvana. Pickup fees may apply. Thank you to Kumiko.
[00:10:02] I agree that a raise doesn't need to make every part of your life more expensive, but I do think there's a way to use percentages without treating them as instructions to spend. For example, maybe you've set aside money for eating out and near the end of the month, you still have some left. If you think of that amount as something you're supposed to use, you might go looking for another dinner to buy. But if it's simply the most you're willing to spend, you don't need another purchase to complete the budget.
[00:10:32] You can spend less and still have followed your plan. And you can decide ahead of time what happens to that difference. Maybe unused restaurant money goes toward a trip you're planning. Or maybe you keep it available for a month when you have more plans. That gives the leftover money somewhere to go without making you feel like you should use it up before the month ends. So thank you again to Kumiko. And thank you for spending part of your day here with me. I'll be back tomorrow as usual.
[00:11:02] So I'll see you there where your optimal life awaits. Hey guys. I'm Daniel Shearsley.



